HOME MyTRB CONTACT US DIRECTORY E-NEWSLETTER FOLLOW US RSS


The National Academies

NCHRP 15-77 [Active]

Aligning Geometric Design with Roadway Context

  Project Data
Funds: $349,986
Staff Responsibility: B. Ray Derr
Research Agency: Kittelson & Associates
Principal Investigator: Brian Ray
Effective Date: 6/18/2020
Completion Date: 12/17/2021
Comments: Draft final report is under review

OBJECTIVE

 

The objective of this research is to draft Part IV (Facility Design in Context) of the proposed eighth edition of the Green Book (GB8), using a consistent structure for the context chapters and drawing content from the Green Book and research-based sources. This material should be suitable for direct use in a future project to develop the GB8, although the development of Parts I-III may prompt changes.

STATUS

The draft final report is under review.

 

TASKS

 

Task 1. Survey state DOTs, members of the National Association of City Transportation Officials (NACTO), and, if appropriate, other agencies to locate innovative design manuals and standards.

 

Task 2. Review domestic and international literature for potential Part IV content. This review should address all modes of travel.

 

Task 3. Synthesize approaches for organizing the Part IV context chapters (Chapters 14-19). Evaluate those approaches based on several criteria, including (1) clarity of the organization; (2) treatment of the road’s functional class; (3) placement of material related  to pedestrians, bicyclists, transit, and freight; (4) usefulness to different audiences (e.g., designers, planners, local stakeholders); and (5) alignment with how state and local agencies organize their design standards.

 

Task 4. Present the project plan and the Task 3 approaches to the AASHTO Technical Committee on Geometric Design to obtain feedback on the scope and organization of the Part IV chapters.

 

Task 5. Submit an interim report by November 2020, summarizing the work done in Tasks 1-4 and including an annotated Part IV outline, format and presentation examples, and a process for resolving conflicts among sources. The annotated outline should clearly identify references to material expected to be included in Parts I-III of the GB8 and to external sources (e.g., Guide for the Development of Bicycle Facilities, Highway Safety Manual, Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices, Access Management Manual).

 

Task 6. Draft the Part IV chapters. These chapters should present appropriate applications and ranges of design controls, criteria, and elements that are considered appropriate for all modes of travel. The material should reflect a performance-based design process that considers a broad range of design choices and applies to all project types (i.e., new construction, reconstruction, projects on existing roads).  The material will allow the identification of potential areas of concern and determination of the tradeoffs required to best achieve the project’s purpose and need statement. When sources present conflicting recommendations, these should be identified. The draft chapters should identify gaps in knowledge that should be addressed in future efforts.

 

Task 7. Conduct a workshop on the Urban Core Roadways chapter for NACTO and the Suburban Roadways chapter for the Institute of Transportation Engineers. These workshops are expected to (1) access technical expertise on roadways that are usually not the responsibility of state DOTs; (2) improve the applicability and utility of the material; and (3) identify design issues faced in these contexts that need further research. These workshops should address all modes of transportation and include examples of how the chapter material could be applied to real-world design projects.

 

Task 8. Present at least 4 professional webinars (e.g., Association of Pedestrian and Bicycle Professionals, American Planning Association, American Public Transportation Association) to build awareness of the GB8 development and to solicit feedback on the content of the draft Part IV chapters that is important to their clientele.

 

Task 9. Submit the final deliverables including (1) a final report that documents the entire research effort; (2) presentation materials; and (3) a stand-alone technical memorandum titled “Implementation of Research Findings and Products.” The final report should briefly describe the work done and present the draft Part IV chapters and include the following appendixes: (1) Task 7 examples; (2) feedback from Tasks 7 and 8; and (3) recommendations for the development of Parts I-III of the GB8. These deliverables are expected to be published by the NCHRP so that state and local transportation agencies can begin to incorporate them into their standards and manuals while the proposed GB8 development effort is underway.

BACKGROUND

 

Since 1984, AASHTO’s A Policy on the Geometric Design of Highways and Streets (the “Green Book”) and other roadway design criteria have been primarily based on a functional classification system of a hierarchical network composed of arterials, collector, and local roads. This classification was further assigned by an urban or rural designation. This system is described in detail in Highway Functional Classification Concepts, Criteria, and Procedures (FHWA-PL-13-026).

 

In May 2016, the AASHTO Standing Committee on Highways (SCOH) passed a resolution on Direction on Flexibility in Design Standards. This resolution tasked the Committee on Design to develop guidance, for users of the Green Book, on flexibility in design that is multimodal, research-based, and peer-reviewed. That guidance should educate users on the flexibility inherent in the Green Book and provide new and additional guidance on specific design issues. It should also lead other AASHTO publications toward a future set of flexible design standards.

 

The AASHTO Technical Committee on Geometric Design (Technical Committee) reviewed NCHRP Report 785: Performance-Based Analysis of Geometric Design of Highways and Streets; NCHRP Research Report 839: A Performance-Based Highway Geometric Design Process; NCHRP Research Report 855: An Expanded Functional Classification System for Highways and Streets; and other references to determine how the seventh edition of the Green Book could satisfy, at least in part, the SCOH resolution. Chapter 1, New Framework for Geometric Design, was added to emphasize the importance of explicitly stating the purpose and need of a project; introduce the context classes presented in NCHRP Research Report 855 (i.e., rural, rural town, suburban, urban, and urban core); stress that all transportation modes should be considered in design; point out the flexibility that can be brought to the design of new construction, reconstruction, and projects on existing roads; and recommend a performance-based approach to design. Changes were made in other chapters to reflect the SCOH resolution as resources and time allowed before publication in 2018.

 

The Technical Committee on Geometric Design also commissioned NCHRP Project 20-07/Task 423, “Planning for a Comprehensive Update and Restructuring of AASHTO’s A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets (8th Edition),” to help them plan for the eighth edition of the Green Book (GB8). The Technical Committee and Committee on Design envisioned the GB8 as fully satisfying the SCOH resolution and were willing to consider a total restructuring to support a flexible, multimodal, performance-based, and context-sensitive design process. That project reviewed the previous research and conducted significant outreach to develop recommendations. At its July 2019 meeting, the Technical Committee reviewed the recommendations from NCHRP Project 20-07/Task 423 and decided to adopt the following outline. This outline was presented to the AASHTO Council on Highways and Streets in October 2019.

Part

Chap.

Title

Part I—Introduction

1

Overview

2

Performance-Based Design Concepts

3

Design Decision Making

Part II—Performance-Based Evaluations

4

Performance Metrics

5

Design Model

6

Applying a Performance Based Process Framework

Part III—Geometric Elements and Configurations

7

Design Information and Sources

8

Elements of Design

9

Cross-Section Elements

10

Intersection Fundamentals

11

Freeways and Controlled Access Fundamentals

12

Interchange Fundamentals

Part IV—Facility Design In Context

13

Context and Facility Type Considerations

14

Rural and Natural Areas

15

Rural Towns

16

Suburban Roadways

17

Urban Roadways

18

Urban Core Roadways

19

Industrial, Warehouse, or Port Roads

 

One of the major changes is Part IV that will build upon the context classes in NCHRP Research Report 855 and Chapter 1 of the Green Book, seventh edition. Some of the reasons for this addition are:

  • The context classes better delineate the needs of all users of the roadway and provide a linkage to the land use.
  • The context class of the road will often influence design decisions more than the functional class of the road.
  • This approach better reflects the state of the practice and emerging design issues, including context-sensitive design, livable communities, practical design, and complete streets.
  • This organization could reduce redundancies in the existing Green Book text while also allowing more specificity in recommendations for design solutions and evaluation of tradeoffs.
  • These chapters should promote consistency in how these context classes are defined and applied across the United States.
  • The reorganization will allow a fresh look at the content of the Green Book and help identify areas for improvement.

Research is needed to determine how the current design guidance in the Green Book and other good sources can be reorganized by context class. Production of the GB8 will be done in a larger, subsequent effort.


To create a link to this page, use this URL: http://apps.trb.org/cmsfeed/TRBNetProjectDisplay.asp?ProjectID=4766